I tried two more distributions this week. I would rate one as my highest recommendation.

SimplyMEPIS is a fantastic distribution. It is based on Debian. I loved the desktop layout and feel. The one killer problem was that the setup did not include my monitor.

Sante Fe is a close second. Also based on Debian and had the same problem with my monitor. The resulting monitor flicker was a deal breaker. I will check back from time to time because these are both winners.